Artificial Intelligence (AI) is the worst thing to hit journalism in a lifetime.
We're already seeing the effects of AI where it generates inaccurate or misleading information in newsrooms across the nation. Public trust in the news is sinking faster than the Titanic when it hit an iceberg. It's already obvious that AI can potentially replace some aspects of a journalist's work with automated content creation. The quality and ethics of AI raises many concerns.
Last year experts warned Congress that AI poses a grave threat to journalism. Media executives and academic experts testified before the Senate Judiciary Subcommittee on Privacy, Technology, and the Law about how AI is contributing to the big tech-fueled decline of journalism.
Those experts explained that the rise of big tech has been directly responsible for the decline in local news. "First Meta, Google and OpenAI are using the hard work of newspapers and authors to train their AI models without compensation or even crediting the source," said Senator Richard Blumenthal during the hearing.
The result? Using these models to compete with newspapers and broadcasters has cannibalized readership and revenue from the journalistic institutions that generate the content in the first place.
Since the rise of the digital platforms a decade ago the tech companies and the news industry have been in conflict, which has resulted in tech platforms profiting as many news organizations have gone out of business. Researchers at the Medill School of Journalism, Media, Integrated Marketing Communications at Northwestern University found that America has lost almost a third of its newspapers and almost two-thirds of its newspaper journalists since 2005.
Fighting Back
Countries around the world are starting to take action to force big tech to support their local journalism industries. I like what Canada did in 2023 when they passed a law requiring tech companies to pay news outlets for any content featured on their platforms. Australia led the way with a similar law in 2021.
Here in the United States, there have been numerous lawsuits between big tech and the news industry. The New York Times vs OpenAI last year has been the highest profile case yet.
Billions of dollars in statutory and actual damages have been charged against OpenAI who responded by claiming it actually helped support a healthy news ecosystem. The case is ongoing.
The news industry has borne the brunt of having to vet content in order to determine whether AI stories are genuine and accurate. One example; following the Oct. 7, 2024, terrorist attacks on Israel, fake photos and videos reached an unprecedented level in social media in a matter of minutes! Of the 1000s of videos that one broadcast network sifted through to report on the attacks, only 10% of them were authentic and usable.
While Congress dilly-dallies around this AI threat it continues to expand like a cancer in all of the communication platforms. It's no wonder that the American public is losing faith in newspapers and broadcasters. There's never been a greater threat to our democracy than what AI poses today.
As it Stands, democracy does die in the darkness. The Washington Post is a good example because AI tech and a right-wing publisher have turned off the lights.